Monday, October 12, 2009

UFology pseudoscience lab

This is a paper I had to write for my Understanding Science Class at Weber. It's not so formal as my other masters classes and it's definelty not written in APA. I guess that might just mean it's more readable.

-Laura

UFology


The extraterrestrial hypothesis (ETH) claims that some UFO sightings are alien spacecraft. “A sub-set of the ETH, the Staging Hypothesis, prevalent up until the 1980s, speculated that extraterrestrials have "stage-managed" encounters as a deliberate policy to "educate" humanity.” Ufologists Wilhelm Reich and Jerome Eden have the hypothesis that UFOs and UFO passengers, or at least some of them, are hostile. They claim that the waste product of the UFO engines is what they call "Deadly Orgone," which ruins the atmosphere, dries it out, and is one cause, if not the most important cause, of the development of deserts. Eden, like other researchers, attributes the Cattle mutilations to aliens. They claims that aliens abduct persons, manipulate their feelings and thoughts, and cause military aircraft to crash or disappear, but they do not make open contact to government or military. They also claim that aliens try to "educate" mankind in the way that the human beings develop a spiritual attitude towards aliens and UFOs, hoping that the aliens arrive as the saviors for the big problems of mankind and earth, when, in fact, their agenda involves exploiting Earth's natural resources and destroying its water and atmosphere. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ufology) In general, Ufologists claim that alien life exists, has made visits to Earth, and continues to make visits to Earth.

Most UFO websites will provide physical evidence in the form of electro-magnetic effects, vehicle interference cases (where a car or other vehicle's performance is disrupted), physical trace cases (“Usually these involve a landing trace, such as depressed grass or soil, but also burned or broken vegetation, residues, and more exotic traces” (www.ufoevidence.org/topics/physicaltracecases.htm), physiological effects, and radar cases/readings. Other than “physical” evidence, a majority of Ufologist's beliefs and theory seems to be based on accounts of people.

The Ufologists from ufoevidence.org claim that Dr. Edgar Mitchell, an astronaut from the Apollo 14 mission, is now claiming that UFOs do exist, the government knows about it, and they're hiding it from ordinary citizens. Ufologists from ufoevidence.org utilize an appeal to authority, specifically pointing out Dr. Mitchell's qualifications, and use those qualifications as “proof” of the validity of Ufologist claims. The interview states, “Dr Mitchell, who has a Bachelor of Science degree in aeronautical engineering and a Doctor of Science degree in Aeronautics and Astronautics claimed Roswell was real and similar alien visits continue to be investigated.”

As Robert L. Park states in The Seven Warning Signs of Bogus Science, “The discoverer says that a powerful establishment is trying to suppress his or her work.” Ufologists claim that governments know the truth about UFO's and aliens, but are doing their best to keep the truth from the public. (http://www.ufoevidence.org/topics/Government.htm) Ufologists play on the natural human tendency to question authority by seeding distrust in government as a means to validate their own claims. Ufologists use both appeal to authority, and in contrast, encourage a distrust of authority, as arguments for UFO/alien existence.

When I was much younger I was camping in my grandparents back yard for the night. I was alone, stargazing, and I noticed that when I was in my tent some of the stars looked elliptical and larger than other stars and then when I stuck my head out of the tent the ellipses disappeared. I convinced myself that these ellipses were UFO/aliens, and that they could see me if I stuck my head out of the tent. For quite some time I was paralyzed with fear, unwilling to stick my head out of the tent door, even though I had to use the bathroom very badly. Finally my bladder could take no more and I rushed out of my tent. When I looked up and saw the stars a thought came to me- those ellipses I saw in my tent might not be UFO's, but merely a result of the netting at the roof of my tent distorting the appearance of the stars. When I returned to my tent I felt rather foolish, realizing that I had allowed my being alone at night to make me paranoid enough to think something with a simple explanation could be something entirely different.

UFOlogists take verifiable information and events, like optical phenomena (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_phenomenon), and milk extraordinary conclusions from them. Just like I combined an ordinary optical allusion (tent netting/stars) with ordinary human psychology (fear, isolation, paranoia) and concluded that aliens were above me and could see me. Take away human fleeting emotions and thoughts, and you are left with simple, everyday events.

Ufology is a pseudoscience; it includes several of Park's “indicators” of pseudoscience, including, a focus on a powerful establishment trying to suppress the work, limited detection, evidence is anecdotal, past evidence is used as a support for modern validity (ufoevidence.org/topics/general-ancientastronauts.htm), and new laws of nature must be made to explain observation (hyper.net/ufo/summary.html). Personally I do believe that unexplainable things can and do happen all the time. However Ufology appears to be more of a exploitation, intentional or otherwise, of human psychology, as opposed to anything valid or really extraordinary.

As a human and citizen it is important to recognize something as a pseudoscience so that one does not get caught in a mental, emotional, time-consuming or financial trap. As an educator it is important to teach students about the differences between fact and fiction, reliability and folly. The objective of science should be to find the answers to questions about how things really are. Science shouldn't be about how things appear to be, or seem to be, but as they really are. As a science instructor, teaching students how to discern between reality and appearances can help them not only in their science studies, but with every aspect of their lives.

Monday, October 5, 2009

I love this song

I could listen to this song 20 times in a row- and I have.

Colors of the Wind


So basically I love Disney's Pocahontas! I know, it's unrealistic, but who cares! Cinderella was unrealistic, Aladdin, Pinnochio- all of them, because they're fairy tales. Pocahontas is just a modern-American fairy tale. My American Indian History teacher (from highschool) said it romantisized American Indians and he called it "Hoax-upon-us", but like I said, whatever!
Anyway, now that we've moved on past that issue...I was just thinking, how great is the song "Colors of the Wind"!? For funsies I thought it would be cool to find scriptures that correlate with the lyrics, becasue that's just how I roll! To make it simple and legit, I've linked the lyrics to the scriptures etc. at LDS.org, have fun!
Here are the (Vanessa Williams version) lyrics:

You think you own whatever land you land on
The earth is just a dead thing you can claim
But I know every rock and tree and creature
Has a life, has a spirit, has a name (It's wonderful; it changed my life & how I think about everything)
(Also  D&C88:13) (Also Moses 3:5)

You think the only people who are people
Are the people who look and think like you (2 Nephi 26:33)
But if you walk the footsteps of a stranger
You'll learn things you never knew you never knew (hymn 29, especially verse 7)

Have you ever heard the wolf cry to the blue corn moon
Or asked the grinning bobcat why he grinned ? (It seems to me that if God knows and loves all of His creations, he wouldn't want us to abuse or mistreat them. We should love God's creations and creatures- Moses 1:35)
Can you sing with all the voices of the mountain ?
Can you paint with all the colors of the wind ? (One of my all-time favorites, D&C 128:23)
Can you paint with all the colors of the wind ? (The beauty and wonder of the Earth are testimonies of God's love)

Come run the hidden pine trails of the forest (D&C 89:20)
Come taste the sun-sweet berries of the earth (Moses 2)
Come roll in all the riches all around you (Gen. 2:9)
And for once, never wonder what they're worth (D&C 56:17)

The rainstorm and the river are my brothers (D&C 61:14; Gen. 1:20; Rev. 8:10) (Also see Abraham 4)
The heron and the otter are my friends (The 8th set of song lyrics he mentions, about shooting birds)
In a cirle, in a hoop that never ends (D&C 132:19-24)

Have you ever heard the wolf cry to the blue corn moon (D&C 88:6-13)
Or let the eagle tell you there hes been (Deut. 14:12- Don't Eat eagles!)
Can you sing with all the voices of the mountain ? (Isaiah 44:23)
Can you paint with all the colors of the wind ? (Mark 4:37-41)
Can you paint with all the colors of the wind ? (Genesis 1:1- God really DID paint the colors of the wind, and someday so can I!)

How high does the sycamore grow ?
If you cut it down, then youll never know (1 Nephi 15:36- How high can our eternal glory grow?! Don't you want to find out? The better I live, the better my reward will be! Thank you George Harrison!)

And you'll never hear the wolf cry to the blue corn moon (D&C 88:45)
For whether we are white or copper-skinned (1 John 4:7- Love everyone, God does!)
We just sing with all the voices of the mountain (Isaiah 40:9)
Need to paint with all the colors of the wind (The Work of Creation)
You can own the earth and still
All you'll own is earth until
You can paint with all colors of the wind (One last gem for you! Be nice to the animals and the earth!)

Amazing talk!

Friday, October 2, 2009

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

The Hot Chocolate Effect

In my Understanding Science MED course we did the classic Hot Chocolate Effect experiment.


You make hot chocolate- hot water + cocoa powder + mix=hot chocolate
 After stirring you tap your spoon (this works with plastc, metal or wooden spoons- who knows what else?!) in the cup- and guess what?! The pitch of the tapping rises! What happens if you stir it again? Well the pitch starts low and rises again! Good times!

So my lab partner suggested we make it legit and record our findings in his sound recording studio! Here are the results:

This is what Ron Proctor, who understands this all much better than me, said,
This is, "the audio spectrograph from yesterday's hot chocolate escapade. The left one is regular hot chocolate, the left is sugar free (that's my lab partner and I talking in the middle there). Horizontal axis = time, vertical axis = Logarithmic Frequency (Hz).

Anyway, for some reason the regular hot chocolate's pitch raised a lot more progrssivly, while the sugar free took an immediate jump up! The bright horizontal lines are the pitch rizing. The vertical lines are my spoon taps.

The point- SCIENCE IS FUN. DO SCIENCE OR DIE.

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

So I've moved.

That's right stalkers, I've moved to Ogden, Utah!

Despite the bitter cold (It's September and I'm already cold?! I'm going to freeze to death!) I'm actually liking the Mormon-packed North. As you know at this point, I like to blog via-lists, and so here we go:

Good things about Ogden:
1. Peery's Egyptian Theater
2. Ott Planetarium3. Fun roommates




4. Ogden LDS Temple 5. I live close to Khiah!6. I like Weber State and my institute classes are sweet-a!


7. Riding the bus
Icky things about Weber:
1. Cold/snow
2. crime rate
3. Creepers on the bus

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Bob Dylan explains my life

I really do promise to do a real blog, but for the time being here is a little time filler:

Using only song names from ONE ARTIST, cleverly answer these questions. Pass it on to 15 people you like and include me. You can't use the band I used. Try not to repeat a song title. It's a lot harder than you think! Repost as "my life according to (band name)"

Pick your Artist: Bob Dylan

Are you a male or female: Girl From The North Country

Describe yourself: Covenant Woman

How do you feel: It's all good

Describe where you currently live: Maggie's farm

If you could go anywhere, where would you go? Sante Fe'

Your favorite form of transportation: Shooting star

Your best friend(s)? Lenny Bruce

You and your best friends: Katie's Been Gone or Jolene or Joey or Jim Jones

Favorite time of day: Moonlight or Meet me in the morning

If your life was a TV show, what would it be called: Idiot Wind

What is life to you: I feel a change comin' on

Your relationship: Lovesick

Your fear: Motorpsycho nightmare

What is the best advice you have to give: Lay, Lady, Lay

Thought for the Day: Man gave names to all the animals
How I would like to die: Knockin' on heaven's door

My soul's present condition: I am a lonesome hobo

My motto: I shall be free